Past Miss Crawford County Titleholders |
| 2008 | Brittani DeVore | 1981 | Penny (Shreve) Varee |
| 2007 | Shauna Rice | 1980 | Jana (Glenzer) Goodrich |
| 2006 | Ashley Borchilo | 1979 | Wallene (Probst) Frank |
| 2005 | Melissa Frances Pierce | 1978 | Pamela (Groves) Christ |
| 2004 | Alycia Darby McCullough | 1977 | Laura Bloom |
| 2003 | Kelsey Marie Stanton | 1976 | Leann (Bleakney) Smith |
| 2002 | Kimberly L. Wilson Hernandez | 1975 | Sharon Stone |
| 2001 | Kelly Rae Frampton | 1974 | Linda (Clark) Lazzeroni |
| 2000 | Alison Irwin | 1973 | Frances (Logue) Stone |
| 1999 | Heather Rose Chapman | 1972 | Lori Doutt |
| 1998 | Lorielle Christine Gillette-Inkley | 1971 | Jan (Amboyer) Wolliscroft |
| 1997 | Danielle Lin Bazylak | 1970 | Janet (Mead) White |
| 1996 | Melissa Poraczky | 1969 | Cindy (Styborski) Ebert |
| 1995 | Heather (Clancy) Young | 1968 | Connie (Williams) Welch |
| 1994 | Jennifer (Held) Lewandowski | 1967 | Karen (Anderson) Bourquin |
| 1993 | Elizabeth Ann Stuyvesant | 1966 | Diane (Sheets) Mariani |
| 1992 | Rae Jean (Stephens) Catrabone | 1965 | Kathe (Rudd) McKay |
| 1991 | Amy (Burhoe) Middleton | 1964 | Sandy (Steiger) Schrecengost |
| 1990 | Wendy Jill (Cavett) Plyer | 1963 | Joyce (Curran) Williams |
| 1989 | Jeanne Maria (Stein) Thorndike | 1962 | Sally (Mollenauer) Coleman |
| 1988 | Amy (Burhoe) Middleton | 1961 | Kathy (Stevenson) McGrath |
| 1987 | Karen (Passilla) Green | 1960 | Marie (Furno) Van Wellengham |
| 1986 | Leigh Ann (Karpinski) Finley | 1959 | Lisa (Louis) (Ellis) Groff |
| 1985 | Allison (Ogello) Schoonover | 1958 | Patricia (DeLoss) O'Brien |
| 1984 | Jane Smith | 1957 | Judy (Levenhagen) Mann |
| 1983 | Kathleen (Arent) Haberman | 1956 | Cecile (Martin) Richard |
| 1982 | Wendy Sue (Kaufman) Seeley | 1955 | Elsie Douglas |
